Home  |  Links  |  FAQ  |  Locations  |  Contact Us

Hartzler Family Dairy


Because of the increased demand for Hartzler's Butter, we have had to procure another supplier of cream.  Hartzler butter is:

  • Locally produced
  • Artificial Hormone Free
  • Low Temperature Vat Pasteurized

We've had a few people ask us why we don't say that our butter is grass-fed or all natural.  Here is what we've told them:

We understand your concern regarding Hartzler butter production and are so thankful for customers such as yourself. However, what you may not know is that there is a cream shortage all over this area. Due to this shortage, we basically have two options: (1) only make butter with the small amount of cream that Hartzler's has available. That would end in a butter shortage and in turn, the price would skyrocket -maybe even triple price for the butter. Or (2) we could source the best cream that is available right now and continue to produce local, artificial hormone free, and low temperature pasteurized butter. That is what we've chosen to do. We are continually looking for other local sources of cream and will update our website if anything changes. Thank you so much for your care and concern regarding our products!   ~The Hartzlers


Our butter is sold in 2 pound rolls -- salted or unsalted. If your recipes call for 2 sticks or 1 cup then how does that convert? Check out this table for a cheat sheet.







5 1/3



1/12 roll





1/8 roll





1/4 roll

 1 1/2




3/8 roll





1/2 roll


Our butter comes in 2 pound rolls salted or unsalted. Delicious for cooking!


Signup for our newsletter!

It's full of health tips, recipes and news you can use.

Current Newsletter

Did You Know?

cow moves her jaw more than 40,000 times On average, a cow moves her jaw more than 40,000 times every day.


What's NOT In Your Organic Milk That Should Be


Hartzler Dairy's Low Temperature Vat Pasteurization method allows us to heat our milk at a lower temperature for a longer period of time, eliminating harmful micro-organisms but leaving valuable enzymes untouched. This is crucial for proper digestion and good health.

Read More

How to Drink Hartzler Milk


"..The Cream Rises to the top"

Whether you drink it straight from the bottle (we won't tell your mom), or from a favorite glass, there's one thing you need to do first: SHAKE BEFORE DRINKING! That's because our milk is all natural and the cream rises to the top -- that's what makes our milk healthier and tastier than most!

Read More